Sharon D. Clarke stars in Caroline, or Change at the Playhouse Theatre

Absolutely brilliant. Fantastic singing, great set pieces, just lovely. Been twice and will be going again.

Extremely disappointing show. My wife and I (who are both English born) couldn't make head or tail of the story line nor did we understand the significance the lady in the silver costume, the three lady singers, the man playing the clarinet and virtually everything else. We walked out at the interval, something we have never done before. We noticed several others doing the same. We see a lot of musical shows in the West End but this must have been the most disappointing and we very much regret paying our hard-earned money for seats 15 and 16 in row H for last night's performance. We can't understand the critic's rave reviews - they must be seeing something we missed. On our way out, we spoke to James, an usher and expressed our disappointment. He did his best to explain the show and as he said "it's like Marmite, you either love it or hate it". We belong to the latter category

Unbelievably mind numbingly pretentious rubbish!! The cast are fantastic (amazing voices) but the story is truly awful!!

Loved the show. Amazing voices. Maybe a little unusual in the staging and presentation of the storyline. Avoid dress circle F2. Not sold as restricted view but could only see 60% of the stage. Shame the theatre doesn't recognise this.

Very poor. Im not sure why this has won awards. The one good thing (and there is only one good thing) is the incredible voice of the leading actress. It was so bad I thought it was about depression. The next day I had to read about the show on the internet to find out that it is about the "evils " of money …. whatever !!

After reading the review from Kate. I was also booked to sit in the upper circle of this theatre. I found there to be plenty of leg room. I am 6ft 1 inch tall. I don't know where she is coming from, perhaps she is a dwarf. By the way show is excellent and so is the performance by Sharon D Clark is which the reason I booked to go and see. I saw her in Ghost. is coming from .Perhaps she is a dwarf. The show was excellent by the way and Sharon D Clar

Wonderful and moving evening, tremendous music and powerful performances, especially from Caroline, a rapt audience throughout

Such an amazing creation: Kushner's usual playfulness and profundity, plus fabulous music. The ensemble are a joy, and Sharon D. Clarke is stunning, stunning, stunning. Standing ovation at our performance.

The cast translated the emotion of the characters perfectly. Outstanding performance!